This is what Superstar LJR and I drank while we discussed the Woody Allen movie we'd just seen (eh, we just go hoping for greatness), her wonderful child (the Boon, proof that evolution works), and whether Jack Wald is dead (not sure):
2001 Nuits-St-Georges," Les Chenes Carteaux," 1er Cru, Domaine Henri Gouges $23
This is elegant Nuits St. Georges. Although quite approachable now, the length and power on the finish make it clear that this is a wine with lots of room to improve in the cellar. It is solid and complex, with nice minerality. Of course, since this vineyard is located directly above Les St. Georges itself, that is not entirely unexpected. But this price is a wonderful thing, more than 1/2 off from the retail price! Somehow, I suspect these will not be around for long. (Keith Wollenberg, K&L Burgundy Buyer, 02/05) Allen Meadows writes: "(a 1 ha parcel of 50 year old vines and this has only been bottled since 1997). This is not as dense or powerful as the Chaignots but trades that for additional finesse and focus. Edgy, almost nervous flavors, sneaky length and fine precision combine to create an impression of real elegance."
A lovely wine that we truly enjoyed. Subtle, that's a word you never hear with American wines except when the critic is trying to define a taste he can't really peg. This does need to age before it's true brillance comes out. The wine club sold out immediately on re-orders. Probably because they've buried us in California Cabs for the last few months. The Boy-Named-Sous tried to re-order and was told it was sold out. I went on line when he told me and was surprisingly sold two more bottles. I talked to the head guy at the wine club, he told me that it shouldn't have happened, that there were people on the waiting list who should have gotten first shot . . . "but, hey, enjoy!" he said. So this one goes in the cellar for a couple of years. Just a tip for those novice wine enthusiasts: never listen to anyone who might call a wine "edgy and nervous". Wine spends it's time mostly in repose and not in therapy.
2002 Torbreck "The Steading," Barossa Valley
Price: $27.99
93 points Robert Parker: "David Powell consistently excels with The Steading, an 8,000 case blend of Grenache, Mourvedre, and Shiraz. Aged 22 months in 300 liter hogsheads (foudres), it represents Australia’s version of Chateauneuf du Pape. The 2002 The Steading’s big, spicy, earthy nose reveals notions of cherry liqueur, licorice, pepper, dried Provencal herbs, raspberries, and leather. Ripe, medium to full-bodied, chewy, and heady, it is best drunk during its first 7-8 years of life, although it will last a lot longer."
Sous and I were all excited about the Burgundy and didn't give much thought to the other wine, the Austrailian. This is because we are victims of our own snobbery. A great Burgundy (Pinot Noir) is orgasmically wonderful and pretty damned rare (which ties into a joke about ex-girlfriends and my "talents" in the . . . never mind). Anyway, we opened this bottle second, but it rocked our world. I didn't taste the Provencale Herbs (you need lavendar for that and there is no, I repeat NO, lavendar in this wine) and the review portrays the wine as heavier than it actually is- I loved it and recommend it to you all.
Rex Goliath 2001 "47 Pound Rooster" Central Coast "Free Range" Cabernet Sauvignon
This wine is named for His Royal Majesty Rex Goliath, who was once the world's largest rooster, or at least Texas'. Even if it seems to have no bearing on what you should expect from the wine in terms of flavor or quality, you must admit that forty-seven pounds is a lot of rooster. In fact, there is an axiom of the classic winemaking tradition at work here: When the product costs only seven dollars, an interesting label might be a good idea. Some of us-and we think you know where we're coming from here-were surprised to discover how delicious this wine actually is. The grapes for Adam LaZarre's free range Cabernet live an unencumbered life in Monterey County-until, that is, they're forced into the servitude of this little powerhouse. Which, with its considerable weight and handsome comb of red fruit, is rather muscular and proud. (5/2003 Jon) [#3 in 2003] Gold Medal Winner, SF Chronicle Wine Competition.
Yet another reason to admire, nay, worship LJR- she has found a great bargain priced Cab! The algerbra in your head makes you question things like: was this, at a third the price, only one third as good at the "The Steading"? Actually, what you ask yourself is was "The Steading" three times as good as the Rooster? Luckily, we can drink both. I'll buy the Rooster for daily drink and a half case of the Steading for overnighters here in Redwood City "Climate Best by Government Test!"
Anyway, a great night with a lovely friend, truly a Good Friday.
Go in Peace